How many points does it take to make a line? If you ask a mathematician, they'd say two, at the very least. Practically however, we are sometimes asked to draw lines with only a single point. Here in the Phoenix Islands, we are trying to assign a trajectory to these reefs to determine whether they are recovering or declining. In other words, we are trying to draw a line, and the big question is which way the line is pointing--up or down?
Coral near Nikumaroro Island from the current expedition (Photo: Jim Stringer)
There are many scientists on this expedition, all assessing PIPA points in various ways--Tuwake is assessing fish diversity, Larry, Greg and Kate are examining planktonic blue water species, and everyone is contributing their thoughts and observations. Greg is the expedition leader and works on all aspects including the deeper parts with the ROV.
Some of us on the science team (David) have many points from the Phoenix Islands, and based on these points, David has qualitatively drawn a line in his head, and is quantitatively drawing a line from his carefully-collected data points. Others of us (Stuart) have only one point from the Phoenix Islands, but Stuart has other points from remote Pacific atolls (mainly the Northern and Southern Line Islands) that he's using to draw his line. Les works on a global network of reef systems with a focus on Brazil, Belize, the Eastern Pacific and Fiji, and he's using these data (along with his lifetime of reef experience) to qualitatively draw a line as he experiences the myriad reef habitats on the Phoenix Islands.
As for me, I'm trying to draw a line with (essentially) only a single point. This is my first time to the Phoenix Islands, and my first real experience on tropical Pacific atolls. I've had plenty of reef experience in the Caribbean, but the reefs have been very different (barrier reefs or patch reefs), and relatively close to human civilization. Still, I have the literature to draw from, so I guess I have multiple (but different) points as well.
Schooling fish near Nikumaroro Island during the current expedition (Photo: Jim Stringer)
So, with all of these different sets of points and different perspectives, what does our collective line look like? Generally (and it's too soon to tell definitively), I think we all agree that the Phoenix Islands are showing some promising signs of recovery and re-growth. We have been observing lots of coral recruits and juvenile corals, and an extremely healthy fish population. Effectively, the fish are doing a thorough job of keeping the substrate closely cropped, and so we see a reef primed for recovery.
There is a lot of available substrate, lots of crustose coralline algae, and, except for some species, there are enough remaining corals to re-seed the population. Thus, I'd say our lines are all pointed upwards, but given each of our different line-drawing strategies, our lines may have different slopes. Part of the excitement and challenge of this trip is to debate and discuss the points on our lines, and to try to reconcile all of our qualitative observations with the quantitative data that we are gathering on every dive to agree on a line that we think tells the story of the Phoenix Islands at this current point in time.
However, beyond the scope of this trip, coral reef scientists are busy gathering data to plot lines to chart the progress or decline of reefs everywhere. Our scientific discipline is full of lines: this reef looks better, this reef looks worse, this reef has more coral, this one less. there is no shortage of lines, moving in all directions. This can be a bit confusing to interpret, especially when trying to implement policy based on the direction and slope of these lines. In the end, it seems that these lines all call for more reef management, more human action to stop overfishing, more creation marine reserves and to temper the effects (and stop!) climate change. Despite all of these data, however, the message hasn't quite yet been embraced globally.
Near McKean Island during the current expedition (Photo: Jim Stringer)
Though these reefs are remote, they have been undeniably impacted by global change (noted in previous posts here, here, here and by David here). Yet, there are still many places in the world that do not protect their oceans. Ocean stewardship is still a relatively new concept with some. There has been important, recent advancement, though. After all, I'm writing this post from the world's largest marine reserve*. Many other reserves are in various stages of completion, and, with hard work, it is still possible to achieve our goal of healthy reefs worldwide. But, we're not there yet. Despite all of these compelling lines, we're still left with the majority of reefs struggling for their very existence.
And so, I leave you with this. We're busy trying to gather data points in order to generate a line. But how many lines does it take to make the point?
-Randi
*At the time this was written in 2009, PIPA was the largest MPA in the world. It remains one of the world's largest.
Phoenix Islands Blog
9/17/09
Points and Lines - Understanding the health of coral reefs
Labels:
conservation,
coral reef health,
PIPA2009,
Randi Rotjan
Facebook Comments
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Phoenix Islands Marine Protected Area (PIPA) is the one of the largest marine protected areas in the world and the largest and deepest World Heritage site on Earth. It was created in 2008 by the Pacific Island nation of Kiribati with support from its partner organizations, New England Aquarium and Conservation International.
The Aquarium is grateful to the Prince Albert of Monaco II Foundation, The Robertson Foundation, GoPro, The Explorers Club and many others for helping to support this expedition.
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
Dr. Randi Rotjan is a research scientist at the Aquarium, with expertise in coral reefs, symbiosis, and climate change. She coordinates the Aquarium’s research partnership with Kiribati on the Phoenix Islands Protected Area (PIPA) and co-chairs the PIPA Science Advisory Committee. She is the Chief Scientist for the current expedition to the PIPA, coordinating the expedition by satellite.
Dr. Sangeeta Mangubhai is an adjunct scientist at the Aquarium. She has been working with the Aquarium since 2000, during the first trip to the Phoenix Islands. This is her fifth trip to PIPA. She is the Chief Scientist onboard the expedition, working with 15 others onboard and Rotjan remotely to study the current El Nino and the impacts on PIPA marine life.
Dr. Simon Thorrold is the Director of the Ocean Life Institute and a Senior Scientist in the Biology Department at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI). He serves on the Science Advisory Committee for the Phoenix Islands Protected Area. He is a co-organizer of the 2015 PIPA Expedition, working closely with Rotjan and Mangubhai to ensure a successful voyage.
View a list of previous blog authors here.
An image watermark specifies a copyright directly in the image, but a copyright can also be clearly indicated in text near the image. Request image use permission with this form.
Bookmark and Share
Tweet |
|
|
Expedition Partners
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
Team Members
Randi Rotjan, PhD
Click to display Randi's posts.Dr. Randi Rotjan is a research scientist at the Aquarium, with expertise in coral reefs, symbiosis, and climate change. She coordinates the Aquarium’s research partnership with Kiribati on the Phoenix Islands Protected Area (PIPA) and co-chairs the PIPA Science Advisory Committee. She is the Chief Scientist for the current expedition to the PIPA, coordinating the expedition by satellite.
Sangeeta Mangubhai, PhD
Click to display Sangeeta's posts.Dr. Sangeeta Mangubhai is an adjunct scientist at the Aquarium. She has been working with the Aquarium since 2000, during the first trip to the Phoenix Islands. This is her fifth trip to PIPA. She is the Chief Scientist onboard the expedition, working with 15 others onboard and Rotjan remotely to study the current El Nino and the impacts on PIPA marine life.
Simon Thorrold, PhD
Click to display Simon's posts.Dr. Simon Thorrold is the Director of the Ocean Life Institute and a Senior Scientist in the Biology Department at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI). He serves on the Science Advisory Committee for the Phoenix Islands Protected Area. He is a co-organizer of the 2015 PIPA Expedition, working closely with Rotjan and Mangubhai to ensure a successful voyage.
View a list of previous blog authors here.
Photo Use
Search This Blog
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(67)
-
▼
September
(47)
- And the hits just keep on coming from the Phoenix ...
- Vinaka vakelevu, NAI'A!
- Bookends, Burritos, and Blogs - Wrapping up the Ph...
- Coming Together To Protect Our Oceans: PIPA's "Sis...
- Phoenix Islands Education Week Story: Technology L...
- David Obura shares his observations from the exped...
- What is a coral transect? How do researchers colle...
- At the edge of existence
- Living a Dream, Part III - Alan Dynner reports on...
- The Final Frontier: Deep Sea Exploration of the Ph...
- Brian Skerry responds to a reader question about p...
- And now for something completely different ...
- Phoenix and Orona
- Assignment Blog--Rising From The Ashes - Coral Ree...
- A fully regenerated reef on Enderbury Island
- Expedition Team Members' Phoenix Islands "Firsts"
- Leaving Kanton Island, A goodbye party photo album
- How the Phoenix Islands Protected Area came to be
- Kanton Island, halfway through the Phoenix Islands...
- Les Kaufman on surveying coral and preparing to ar...
- Points and Lines - Understanding the health of cor...
- Brian Skerry responds to a reader comment - Was th...
- Dive-eat-dive - a typical day in the Phoenix Islands
- Assignment Blog--Brian Skerry: One Fish, Two Fish,...
- The eradication of rats on McKean Island
- Why are sharks important?
- Tukabu Terooko Kiribati and the Phoenix Islands Pr...
- Blue water diving to study deep-sea jellies in Nik...
- Coral reef scientist Randi Rotjan answers student ...
- Shifting Baselines and coral reefs in the Phoenix ...
- Living a Dream, Part II - Alan Dynner reports on b...
- Searching for invasive species on Nikumaroro
- Somewhere over the rainbow...
- Assignment Blog--Brian Skerry photographs fish in ...
- Reporting on fish populations coral bleaching in N...
- First dive photos from Nikumaroro
- One good tern...
- From rough seas to calm preparation in the Phoenix...
- David Obura discusses going back to the Phoenix Is...
- Living a Dream - A Report from the Journey to the ...
- Assignment Blog--Brian Skerry on the Return to the...
- How to make the ocean's surface your ceiling
- We're gonna need a bigger boat...
- Ocean bound from Fiji to the Phoenix Islands
- Crossing the Pacific on the way to the Phoenix Isl...
- Fiji or bust!
- Going back to the Phoenix Islands after seven years
-
▼
September
(47)
0 comments:
Post a Comment